
The Prime Minister went to that FICCI meeting this week and properly tore into the industrialists. He told them straight — you’re not making enough jobs, you’re not paying good salaries, you’re not innovating, and you’re not using the trade deals we signed. And all this after we cut your taxes. Pretty rare for a PM to go at them like that in public.
Surjit Bhalla has written a reply in The Indian Express. Title is almost exactly what you’d expect: “Dear Prime Minister, with due respect, the fault is not in India Inc.” He’s polite, but he’s not holding back.
His point is simple. Companies don’t sit around inventing policies. They react to whatever rules the government puts in front of them. Tariffs, Quality Control Orders, all that stuff — industrialists don’t write those. Government does. If those rules make things expensive or kill competition, then of course companies behave the way they do. Blaming them for responding to the system you yourself created is like the old saying — the thief shouting at the policeman.
Bhalla brings out the numbers too. Salaried jobs have actually gone up a lot over the years — from about 68 million in 2004-05 to nearly 148 million by 2025. Women’s salaried work has more than doubled. Even casual workers’ real wages have risen over the long stretch. Not perfect, mind you. After 2019 salaries slowed down and real wage growth is still thin. But the data doesn’t match the story that India Inc has just been sitting on its hands.
He accepts the 2019 tax cut was a good move. Corporate rate came down from 30 to 22 percent. But he says other costs are still high — especially because of tariffs and all those quality orders. That makes inputs costly, reduces competition, and takes away the pressure to innovate. When there’s less competition, why would companies take big risks?
Bhalla still gives the PM credit. The recent trade deals with Britain and the EU, the push for more openness — those are real. He just says the better way to follow through is not to lecture FICCI, but to keep fixing the rules so that investing, hiring and innovating actually make sense for companies.
The article has already kicked off the usual back-and-forth. Some people say Bhalla is going soft on big business. Others say he’s just stating the obvious — if you write the rules, you own a big part of the result. Bhalla himself put up a short note calling it elite musical chairs: government makes the policy, big industrialists influence it the most, and then everyone picks who to blame depending on what’s convenient.
The frustration is real though. Government has been pushing manufacturing and PLI and trade deals, but private investment hasn’t fully matched the talk. Profits in some places look healthy while wages for a lot of people haven’t moved much. Bhalla’s answer is — start with the policy design, not with the companies that are just playing the game you set up.
That’s basically what he’s saying. Polite language, hard numbers, and a clear line that responsibility begins with the rules the government itself wrote. Whether they agree or not, the piece has pushed the conversation back to incentives instead of just pointing fingers at India Inc.
Sources: Surjit Bhalla’s column in The Indian Express (20-21 November 2026), plus the usual coverage and discussion that followed.
@Rohit Manral